Book Notes: When Coffee and Kale Compete

Last week my friend Rajagopal advised me to read “When Coffee and Kale Compete: Become Great at Making Products People Will Buy

The book introduces the interesting concept of Jobs to be done or JTBD.  What I liked about and made me glued to the 200 pages of the book is one simple thing: Building product for customers, nothing else.

The two core principles of JTBD are about customers:

  • The desire every customer has to improve themselves and their life situations.
  • How customers imagine their lives being better when they have the right solution.

 

I will focus on customers and competitions which the book talks about. These are the notes from from the book.

Customers

  • Customers wants help in making themselves better.
  • Your desire to delight customers will drive you to invent on their behalf.
  • A dissatisfied customer does not complain; he just switches.
  • Customers can tell you of their struggles, how they expect life to be better, and how they interact with the products they use. But they cannot tell you what to do about it.
  • Design your product to deliver customers an ongoing feeling of progress.
  • Customers need to feel successful at every touch point between themselves and your business, not just at the very end when the outcome of an action is realized.
  • A successful product and business will continually improve customers’ lives. As customers use your product to make their lives better, they will face new challenges and desire new goals and outcomes.
  • Products have no value in and of themselves. They have value only when customers use them to make progress.
  • What can we change to better meet your needs?  << Ask your customer, it makes them more comfortable.
  • Talk with customers to learn what messages connect with them. It can be as simple as asking them to describe why they like your product.
  • Studying what customers consider as competition helps you reveal what pushes them to change.
  • Discover what customers value. Learn their expectations at the moment of purchase and/or first use and avoid over engineering solutions.
  • A great deal of waste happens when solutions are developed with features that customers don’t value. Customers value the progress a feature may deliver, not the feature itself.
  • If customers have anxiety over the cost-value relationship of your product, offer a discount.
  • If customers experience anxiety in using your product, find a way to make your product less intimidating.
  • If your product doesn’t help customers make progress, price doesn’t matter.
  • Identify any habits-in-use that keep customers from using your product. Adjust your product to help them along.
  • Comparing the habits of your best customers with the habits of those who recently quit is a great way to figure out how to turn switchers.
  • For customers who’ve stopped using your product, ask them why.
  • Grow your business, reduce churn, and capture more profits by delivering progress to customers.
  • A great salesperson understands that customer “wants” come from the system, not the customer. So, if you want to change “what customers want,” all you have to do is convince them of a Job that is worth getting Done.
  • Do customers a favor: help them visualize making progress. Create marketing and advertising materials that tell customers that you understand their struggle for progress, that help them visualize how life will be better when they have the right solution, and that explain why your product is the right solution.

 

Competition

  • You might think you’re alone in a market or have market superiority, but some unknown competitor might be stealing away your customers. Your only sign that something is wrong is decreasing sales.
  • Competition is defined in the minds of customers, and they use progress as their criterion.
  • Customers don’t define or restrict competition based on the functionality or physical appearance of a product. Instead, they use whatever helps them make progress
  • Studying what customers consider as competition helps you reveal what pushes them to change.
  • How can you beat the competition? Eliminate the need for the customer to make a trade-off.
  • Learn how to think about competition, become better at identifying real threats to your business, create better messaging that properly speaks to what customers consider as competition, and know how you should and shouldn’t design a solution.
  • Don’t assume two products are competitors because they look or function similarly.
  • Confirm that competition exists between products by finding customers who switched.
  • Every innovator, whether creating a new innovation or improving an existing one, should have a clear idea of how his or her customers see competition. When you’re creating a new innovation, you need to answer these
    • What are customers going to stop buying when they start buying our solution?
    • if you’re creating a new feature for an existing product, you need to ask, “What behaviors or other products is this feature going to replace?”

 

Other takeaways:

  • Success stories of founders applying  JTBD.
  • How just building product without taking customer survey resulted in failure of Tata Nano and Godrej ChotuKool. It also mentions how  Godrej repositioned ChotuKool and got success.
  • How creative destruction eat Kodak and made it bankrupt.
  • Why comparing PC with Mainframe or comparing PC sales with smartphones are incorrect.

 

I would like to  thank the author for writing this book because it just talks about how your product should be empowering your customers and making your business profitable.

If you wish to know more about JTBD do follow https://jtbd.info/  for more user stories, techniques and latest updates.  

 

On my own

1st June 2017 was when I was free from my last full time job. It also means since then (aka over a year) I have been on my own.

Looking back at these 360+ odd days, I have realized that I have done good for myself. I feel I have become more calm, healthy and confident.

Most of my time in the last one year has been spent on reading, learning new things like doodling, coding and rebuilding  my mental and physical strength. I have also been occasionally writing my “Random Thoughts”.

I have also spent a good amount of money on coffee, not that I’m complaining about it.  I also happened to meet some extremely talented folks and made some great friends, who are always inspiring me to do better.

On the reading front, I mostly focussed on learning more about guts (our microbiome), human brain, running, keto, intermittent fasting, on writing, philosophy (mostly Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius, Seneca, Osho and Jiddu Krishnamurti) and product development.

I felt scared and lonely at times. One constant question was : “WTF am I doing?”

I can happily say that I will not  die of hunger, will survive. I have some great friends and mentors who are helping and will always be my side on this journey of life exploration.I have been working on some startup ideas and trying to explore some more.

This constant fight with self and struggle to understand “Who am I? ” seems to have made me gritty and system driven.

I would like to share 10 learnings from these 360+ days of my life:

  • Life is too short, living in the present matters the most.
  • Spending time with like minded people is the key to happiness.
  • Physical and mental health is our only asset and it will define our wealth.
  • What you eat, what you read, whom you spend time with and what you listen to will define you as a person. So choose wisely.
  • Real evaluation is in your daily virtues and  life principles.
  • Money is important but not everything, don’t fall for consumerism.
  • Your focus and consciousness will make or break you.
  • Don’t be an asshole, one less on the planet will do good (even in a small sample size).
  • Learning comes by doing: gurus, books, degrees are worth nothing if you are not implementing it on yourself.
  • Life is like a train journey. At every stop we meet new folks and learn new things and then we move on for our new quest

On Advice

Advices are the easiest to come by. They have come from my friends, parents, relatives and even from those I have not met. Advices can be on anything and everything like I have shown in the following sketches.    

Career

Marriage

Programming Languages

Starting Up

Fundraising

My constant struggle :

  • Who should I take advice from?
  • What if they are wrong?
  • Why should I listen to them?
  • Have they tried these on themselves?

Our life is how we see it. It is very short. In the end what matters to us is what defines us. Advices should be taken with a pinch of salt.

Being aware and more conscious about self will do good to us. Otherwise we will screw up.

Being Authentic

Everyone is trying to be like someone else, everyone is looking for success mantra – from reading blog posts of famous entrepreneurs, learning about their daily routines to copying  some hip hop artist look. We have turned into breed of copycats, but for what? Why can’t we be authentic, be as we are?

We are conditioned by our environment (parents, family, teachers, peers, supervisors) to be, act, behave and talk in a society defined protocol. Those who obey it are incentivized to keep at it and others are ostracized.

How many of us are really creative at our workplace? Do we do work the way we want to? How many of us are not micromanaged?

The dynamics created in the early days of capitalism are still widely followed. It was Henry Ford who came up with 40 hour (9-5) work weeks for his factory workers. Since then, we have injected it all domains like work horses/donkeys.

Employees high on coffee and in perfectly micromanaged environment work from early in the morning to the late evening. Some of the lucky ones get incentives like free dinner or free transport and end up working even more hours.

There is no creativity because there is no freedom. Most of the time it is all about copying the design and workflows of competitors.   

On the  weekends we are riding on the consumerism boat shopping merchandises from brands who are able to sell us the feeling of being authentic.

If a guy starts crying over his misery when he is drunk, everyone asks him to be a man and not cry. I have no fucking clue who came up with this shit. All of us cry.

When every decision of our life has turned into a checkbox or todo list, is there any scope left for being authentic?

 

On Algorithms

Algorithms are not new, we have been using it in stock trading, ticket booking  etc. Just that in 2018 we are hearing more about it.

Four interesting scenarios happened in past few years.

  1. Emergence of cloud computing made processing fast cheap.
  2. Newer Open Source and proprietary technologies like Keras and TensorFlow took Deep Learning closer to consumers.
  3. Smartphones and increasing internet penetration led to production of mode data.
  4. Ease of access of information through mobile phones powered with various apps

We have companies like Facebook, Google and Twitter. We are more connected with our peers via them, we exchange every bit of information using one of these mediums.  They know more about us than our government. We are minions on their platform connected to other minions. Our usage on these platform has created a persona of ours. This persona is used by these platforms to target ads and custom news feed (powered by algorithms, these platforms decides what we should see in out timeline).

Want to know what data these companies own about you?

  1. Google
  2. Twitter
  3. Facebook via wired post

I don’t know if it is good or bad. But imagine a few scenarios:

  1. Your friend has passed away but Facebook algorithm does not show you the post about it.
  2. You are a Republican supporter and Democrats have paid to these platform to target you with all bad coverage the of Republican candidate in your region.
  3. You searched for wedding dress and now you see advertisement about it everywhere.
  4. You are suggested by the platform to add or follow your ex-gf/bf.
  5. When Netflix loads only its original in all the options for you to watch.

I get to hear about newer advancement in facial recognition, driverless cars and cures for rare diseases.

These are all good, but at what cost?

  • Making more people unemployed
  • Adding surveillance on citizens
  • Putting our doctors, scientists on autopilot

Time will tell where we are headed in next 20-30 years as algorithms will be taking over everything. It will tell us whom to marry, what to eat, where to travel, which candidate to select for a job, who gets a loan to or who to talk to.

What will happen to our consciousness if everything around us is  driven by algorithms ?

What matters in life

It takes years of survival on this planet to realize that :-

  1. Life is too short, live it now. A bucket list won’t be of much help.
  2. We are all opinionated and live in our own walled garden of thought.
  3. What matters the most is what makes you feel good and yes, you don’t have to hurt others in achieving it.
  4. Small moments of joy matter:
    1. Going for walk with ailing parents.
    2. Playing with your new born kid.
  5. Life is just learning; not a success or failure checklist.
  6. Building anything requires focus.
  7. Close company of friends is needed in life.
    1. They standby you in all situations of life.
    2. They won’t judge you and will be there to cheer for your success and failure.
  8. All your ego, glory, money and fame are short lived.
    1. Have you not seen pigeon’s shit loaded on the statues around you.

What I learnt reading philosophy

I spent a good amount of time reading after quitting my full time job last year. I read on various subjects ranging from food, health, science, literature and philosophy. I found Philosophy the most interesting among them all. Some of my favorites were J Krishnamurti, Epicurus, Seneca, Socrates and Marcus Aurelius. I maintain my reading list on Kit.

These are my learnings so far:

  • We have to treat the world as one without any division.
  • We have to live our life moment by moment.
  • Life is very short.
  • We have to let go of our anger, ego and attachments with things or people.
  • Nothing is permanent.
  • Empathy makes you rich.
  • We can only control things which are in our hand so worrying about things which are not in our control will harm us.
  • We have to observe our thoughts (the monkey mind) and not control it.
  • Having a set of virtues and principles is the key to living our life with fulfillment.
  • Appreciate what nature offers us. Take short walks to the woods, listen to birds chirping.
  • Always indulge in any discussion with proper reasoning and logic. Apply the same in everyday life.
  • Living a life of honesty and truth is more satisfying.
  • Happiness and pleasure have 3 key ingredients:
    • Company of close friends who are honest and share the same set of values.
    • Independence to live life on our own conditions not under someone we don’t like.
    • Being aware of our thoughts.
  • We are conditioned since birth about our associations with race, caste, religion, belief et al.
  • Love requires no return favors, it is like a free flowing stream.
  • Anger arises due to conflict and leads to misery and unhappiness.

I will be updating the list as my reading journey evolves.

Monkey Mind & me

Its 12 am and I just returned from Corner House after having Death By Chocolate. I am someone who tries to keep himself away from sugar, but does it always work? I would say NO, the evil side of mind or monkey mind as Naval says, gets its fair share.

Isn’t it amazing that even after knowing the side effect of overstuffing with sugar I ended up eating it?

Am I being tricked only in the above scenario?

Nope, there are many other examples.

At the middle of the night I would go to Meghana Foods too sometimes. I am well aware that their food is substandard and I end up getting boils all over my face.

I have deleted Twitter app but somehow I still access it via the web browser. I have been only been partially successful at it.

Another stupid thing this monkey mind does is: adds as much pessimism as it could and watch you suffer.

  • Your idea sucks & you are doomed to fail.
  • You don’t belong here.
  • Spotlight effect Et all.
  • —————–
  • ——————–

What is the cure?

1. Being more aware and watching monkey mind.
2. Being more hopeful and optimistic.
3. Rewarding myself everytime I win.

Am I the only one finding himself in such scenarios?
Is monkey mind going to win?

What is your remedy?

Socrates and his questionings

Socrates bought a fresh way of seeing any situation, thinking and responding to any challenge, conversation. Socrates, a famous Greek philosopher and founder of Western Philosophy [Wikipedia].

According to Socrates a truth is always outcome of discussion filled with logic and reason. Like other Stoic philosopher, he too stressed on having a human life filled with Virtues.

In most encounters and debates, he stressed on reasoning and truth instead bias and prejudice which society and people had put upon.

In what we call now is Socratic way of enquiry, an observation and analysis based on facts and available truths.

It is an irony that 500 people voted on the fate of Socrates on compliance of 3 individuals under incompetent judges with least of the knowledge on the subject. Also that he was not given enough time to talk on his defence during proceeding.

Although his method of asking questions with any strangers on the street of Athens would definitely have gone in major resentment. I guess it would have been altogether a different ball game in modern era of Twitter, we are virtually connected and asking questions and answering to anyone and everyone. 🙂

Some core learnings:
  • Do not believe in everything told to you or shared by others.
  • Stop living a life under prejudice, conditioning and rules.
  • Reason and do observe make an absolute inquiry before taking any decision.
  • On conversation or argument don’t be emotional but be thoughtful. Ask questions, be logical filled with proper reasoning

Sometimes I wonder what Socrates would have said about new age technologies like Crypto, AR/VR or ICO’s. Would he had followed the herd and fallen for FOMO(fear of missing out) or would have made proper reasoning before venturing into it.

Fun Fact:

Socrates has not written any book. There were no mobile devices or tape recorders. Most of his sayings are essentially notes collected by Plato, Crito and other philosophers who were present during  his famous debates.

 Reference: The Consolations of Philosophy

We are all Epicurus

Epicurus was Greek philosopher and founder of school of philosophy named Epicureanism. Centre of his Philosophy revolved around pleasure.

According to Epicurus: “Pleasure is the beginning and the goal of a happy life”

The school of philosophy aka Epicureanism was started on donation from wealthy people because they resonated with it. He spent all the money in setting up the school to promote happiness.

It was one of the first school which was co-ed, male and females both admitted and encouraged to  live and study pleasure.

Spreading rumors were part of our older society as well and regular leaks were common, some related to stories around sexual encounters and others on the day to day functioning of the institute.

Despite all this Epicurus popularity and teaching only grew more.

Two key questions that was asked or enquired were:

  1. What will make me happy?
  2. What will make me healthy?

It should not come as a surprise to us but Epicurus belief had significant inspiration from Socrates.

Once Epicurus asked his friend “Send me a pot of Cheese, so that i may have a feast whenever i like.”  Isn’t it surprising, a teacher of pleasure having such simple eating habit?

Epicurus observed that pleasure has few simple ingredients:

Friendship

Epicurus observed that centre of happiness is having company of great friends. He once said “Feeding without friend is the life of LION or a WOLF.

Later in his life, he moved on the outskirts  of Athens bought a big house and stayed rest of his life there with company of his close friends.

  • True friends are like parents, who are not going to judge you on who and how you look but be there for you as who u are.
  • Having true friends worth more than fortune.

Freedom

We must have freedom to choose course of our life. We don’t have to work or listen to people whom we don’t like.

Thought

Our thoughts defines and brings misery or pleasure to us. Keeping a rational and self analyzed view will be a good way to get over the anxiety about money, wealth and other things.

Summary

Beyond food, shelter and cloths [roti, kapra and makaan], one does not require any worldly wealth to attain happiness.

I sometimes wonder, how Epicurus would have acted or his teaching would have changed in our current world. The world where we are running for:

  • Social media popularity.
  • Car, vacation, long drive and weekend gateways

Although

  • We have more followers on Instagram/Twitter than friends talk to in real life.
  • We spend more on pets and they value more than friends (Am sure PETA folks will disagree to this)
  • We are more worried about next switch than current job in hand.

Reference: The Consolations of Philosophy